When Bass Pro Shops and Schulte Hospitality Group announced in mid-October that they would partner to acquire the Islander at mile marker 82 oceanside, they did not disclose a purchase price, according to Keys Weekly. The dollar figure they did make public was $500,000, committed by Bass Pro Shops, Johnny Morris, Darryl Schulte and other donors to the Florida Keys History & Discovery Center, which sits on the Islander's grounds.
The rest of the plan to unite the two resorts is still being written. For a local, that makes the museum's November and December calendar the first part of this new arrangement you can attend in person.
How Two Resorts Ended Up With One Operator
The sequence ran from June into October. Bass Pro Shops announced its purchase of Cheeca Lodge on June 16, Keys Weekly reported in June. In Bass Pro's Oct. 14 announcement, the company said the Islander was offered for sale after that purchase, and Bass Pro and Schulte "quickly recognized the opportunity for a great partnership."
The two properties are close neighbors with different personalities. According to the Bass Pro announcement, Cheeca has 254 rooms, suites and casitas, a 9-hole Jack Nicklaus-designed par-3 course, a 525-foot historic fishing pier, three pools, a full-service spa, and tennis and pickleball courts. The Islander, established in 1951, covers 24 acres with 114 bungalows and suites, 25 bayside villas, and a long stretch of beach.
The company describes the combined property as almost a mile of private beachfront with nearly 400 accommodations, five pools and six dining experiences. Those figures come from adding the two existing resorts together. Nothing new has been built. The announcement says both resorts "will continue normal operations through the transition while plans are being developed to enhance and unite" them, and that "every effort will be made to retain much of the charm and character" of each.
The leadership comes from inside Islamorada. Joy Michelle Boyd, the Islander's current manager and president of the Florida Keys Resort & Lodging Association Chapter, will lead both resorts. She will work under Debbie Bennett, president of Bass Pro Shops' Nature-Based Hospitality Division and a longtime leader at Big Cedar Lodge. The company says it expects to keep many key team members from both properties and wants to "deepen the connection with the local community."
The only named community commitment so far sits on the Islander's own grounds.
The Museum Behind the Beach Bar
The Florida Keys History & Discovery Center is a 7,500-square-foot museum at Mile Marker 82. It is run by a nonprofit, the Florida Keys History and Discovery Foundation, on the Islander Resort property. Its permanent galleries cover the railroad and the highway, the 1935 hurricane, shipwrecks and wreckers, Indian Key and the first peoples of the islands, coral reefs, seagrass and fisheries, and the fishing history that made Islamorada famous. It also has aquariums, a theater, a research library and a rotating gallery. "Currents & Flows: Power and Water in the Florida Keys," an interactive exhibit, opened in April 2025.
The $500,000 commitment is aimed at the fishing heritage told in those galleries. Keys Weekly reported that the commitment celebrates "the people and places that have helped build the rich fishing heritage of Islamorada as a legendary fishing destination."
The visiting details are simple. The Center is open Tuesday through Sunday from 10 a.m. to 5 p.m. and is closed Mondays. Admission is:
- $15 general
- $12.50 for ages 55 and up
- $6 for students
- $3 for Museums for All EBT and WIC cardholders
- Free for active military and members, and complimentary for NARM cardholders
This Fall, the Center Is Organized Around Food
The current special exhibit is "Florida Keys Cuisine: From Soil to Sea." It brings together historic recipes, archival materials, paintings, photography, ceramics and contemporary stories about how the islands have eaten. The Center's events page is also collecting recipes for an FKHDC Community Cookbook. Several of the programs this season are built around the table, and the first of them is a joint event with the resort next door.
| Date | Program | Details |
|---|---|---|
| Mon., Nov. 9, 6–8 p.m. | Caribbean Night: Tasting Florida Keys Favorites | Raw bar, canapés and desserts, with live music and stories about local foodways. Presented with the Islander Resort. Registration through the Center. |
| Wed., Nov. 11, 6 p.m. | Fall lecture: "The 14th Colony" | Part of the 2026–27 lecture series |
| Wed., Nov. 18, 10:30 a.m. | Coffee with the Curator | Morning program at the Center |
| Mon., Dec. 7, 6–8 p.m. | Holiday baking party | $10 entry, registration required |
| Wed., Dec. 9, 6 p.m. | Fall lecture: "The Florida Sponge War" | Part of the 2026–27 lecture series |
Caribbean Night is the clearest example of how the two neighbors already work together. The Center's listing describes it as "Presented with the Islander Resort, our neighbor just steps away." Registration links for each program are on the Center's events page.
What Stays the Same at the Islander
The museum is the part of the property with a new commitment behind it. Next to it, the Islander's beachfront keeps running as usual, and the places a local already uses are still listed.
The Islander's dining page lists four venues: Tides Beachside Bar, Drift on the Beach, Coccoloba and Sandy's Bar.
- Tides Beachside Bar & Grill is listed as open seven days a week. The kitchen runs 11 a.m. to 10 p.m. Tuesday through Saturday and 11 a.m. to 5 p.m. Sunday and Monday.
- Coccoloba is the one venue whose page names locals alongside resort guests and families. It is currently listed as open Friday and Saturday from 11 a.m. to 4 p.m.
- Sandy's Bar sits poolside, and its hours change with the season, so check with Guest Services.
The Islander's day-pass page offers a discounted Resident Day Pass for Monroe County residents. It includes everything in the standard pass: outdoor pools, beach access, towel service, poolside food and drinks for purchase from Tides, Wi-Fi, self-parking, and bicycles, paddleboards and kayaks when available. The resort requires a valid ID showing Monroe County residency at check-in. Guests without one are turned away and do not get a refund. Guests under 18 must come with an adult. Passes and beach cabanas are booked through ResortPass.
And Down the Shore at Cheeca
Cheeca's dining page lists Atlantic's Edge, Mia Cucina, Nikai Sushi Bar & Restaurant, the Tiki Bar and 25 South, along with a Lobby Coffee Bar & Breakfast Bistro. It posts daily hours for each venue and offers reservation links for Atlantic's Edge and Nikai. Bass Pro's announcement calls the oceanside, poolside bar the "Happy Times" Tiki Bar. Cheeca's long fishing pier is one of the best-known structures on this part of the shore. Cheeca's FAQ describes it as a guest amenity, with poles and licenses provided through Guest Adventures.
The Third Address in the Plan
The Bass Pro announcement names a third property. Cheeca Lodge, the Islander and World Wide Sportsman Store & Marina are meant to work together as one destination. The announcement describes World Wide Sportsman as overlooking Florida Bay, with access to the Everglades and the Gulf Stream, and calls it "a launch point for adventure seekers from Cheeca Lodge and The Islander."
That puts the ocean beaches, the bayside marina and the museum between them under one plan. So far, the plan's only public price tag is the $500,000 for the museum. The next date on that museum's calendar is Caribbean Night on Monday, Nov. 9.
Living near the MM 82 oceanfront means watching changes like this one up close, from the Islander's beachfront to the museum on its grounds. If you'd like to talk through how this stretch of Upper Matecumbe fits the way you live in the Keys, or the way you hope to, Jennifer Hamill would be glad to hear from you. Let's Connect.