Keys News reported that Chef Curtis Duffy said, "I'm truly excited about this partnership with Little Palm Island and Chef Rodrigo." Duffy carries seven Michelin stars across his career. The deal announced in March quietly reset the dinner math for everyone living along this five-mile stretch of the Overseas Highway.
Most news at a private island resort accessible only by boat or seaplane stays contained to the resort. This story doesn't, because the restaurant in question has always kept its door open to the rest of the key.
One Island, One Reservation Book
Little Palm Island sits about three miles off Little Torch Key, reachable only by the resort's own launch or seaplane, capped at 60 guests across 30 thatched-roof suites. It is, by design, one of the most private places to sleep in the continental United States. But The Dining Room, the resort's single restaurant, has never been guest-only. Off-island visitors are welcome for breakfast, lunch, and dinner, and the weekly Sunday brunch has been popular enough on its own to fill the room before any chef headlines existed.
That detail matters more than it sounds. On a key this size, there is no second or third full-service dining room to absorb overflow. Kiki's Sandbar and Tonio's Seafood Shack handle the casual end of the island's appetite, but for a sit-down dinner with white tablecloths and a wine list, The Dining Room has effectively been it. Whatever happens to that single reservation book happens to the whole island's fine-dining option, not just to hotel guests.
What Actually Happened, And When
In March, Little Palm Island announced that Chef Rodrigo Albornoz, who has led the resort's kitchen for over a decade, would begin working alongside Duffy on menu development, technique, and presentation. Albornoz stays in charge of daily service. Duffy's role is closer to a culinary partner shaping where the food goes next, blending what the resort describes as Albornoz's Mediterranean instincts with Duffy's more exacting, technique-driven style. Local business coverage in the Keys reported the collaboration was set to begin in earnest in early May, which means by the time this August high season wound down, the new menus had already been running for a full summer.
Duffy's résumé is the part that makes this more than a hospitality press release. He spent years in Chicago's most demanding kitchens, including Charlie Trotter's, Trio, and Alinea, before opening his own restaurant, Grace, which held three Michelin stars for four consecutive years before closing in 2017. He won the James Beard Award for Best Chef in the Great Lakes region in 2016. His current restaurant, Ever, has held two Michelin stars every year since it opened. He has also appeared on Top Chef, Iron Chef, and The Bear, and his 2025 memoir became a USA Today bestseller. That is not a chef who takes on side projects lightly, and it is not the kind of name that typically attaches itself to a restaurant reachable only by boat on a key most drivers pass without noticing.
The Dining Room already carried some institutional weight of its own. It has picked up Wine Spectator's Best of Award of Excellence every year from 2021 through 2024, and the resort itself rebuilt from nothing after Hurricane Irma destroyed it in 2017, reopening in March 2020 after a $34 million rebuild. The Duffy partnership sits on top of a restaurant that was already taken seriously, which is part of why the reservation pressure is worth planning around rather than shrugging off.
The Island's Three Real Options, Side By Side
For anyone deciding where to eat on a given night, here's how the key's main sit-down spots actually compare right now:
| Spot | Reservation Needed | Dress Code | Typical Wait | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| The Dining Room, Little Palm Island | Yes, call ahead | Collared shirt for dinner, no swimsuits | Longer since spring, especially Sunday brunch | A planned-ahead special dinner |
| Kiki's Sandbar | Walk-in welcome | None, beach casual | Short, seating is mostly outdoor and ample | A weeknight with live music and no plan |
| Tonio's Seafood Shack & Tiki Bar | Walk-in welcome | None | Short | Fried hogfish and homemade key lime pie without ceremony |
What Changes For A Tuesday Night
If you've treated The Dining Room as an occasional splurge you could call about that same afternoon, that window has narrowed. Weekend brunch was already described as especially busy before any of this happened, and a chef with Duffy's profile tends to draw attention from outside the immediate area, which means the table you used to be able to book two days out may now need a full week or more, particularly for Sunday brunch or one of the monthly Full Moon dinners the resort runs on the evening of each month's full moon. Reservations go through the resort directly at 305-422-4236, and the dress expectations haven't loosened: collared shirts for men at dinner, resort-casual for lunch, no beach attire in the dining room itself.
None of this touches the boat ride. The resort's own launch from the Shore Station at mile marker 28.5, a roughly 15-minute trip each way, is still one way to get to the restaurant; seaplane is another. A spontaneous dinner there was never quite as spontaneous as walking into a place on Overseas Highway. If you take the launch, what's changed is the buffer you need to build in before you even get to that boat.
The Backup Plans Haven't Moved
Kiki's Sandbar, right on the highway at 183 Barry Avenue, hasn't changed a thing about how it operates and that's exactly its value right now. Live music runs every night, happy hour runs 4 to 6 p.m. daily, the kitchen is open 11 a.m. to 11 p.m., and boats can dock right at the restaurant. No reservation, no dress code, just a table in the sand or upstairs in the air-conditioned room if the weather doesn't cooperate. Tonio's Seafood Shack & Tiki Bar plays a similar role a short drive away, known locally for a fried hogfish sandwich and key lime pie made the old-fashioned way, no walk-in anxiety required.
That contrast is really the whole story here. The key hasn't grown a dining scene overnight. It has one restaurant that just picked up serious outside attention, and two others that were never trying to compete with it in the first place. If you want a special-occasion dinner with real culinary pedigree behind it, that dinner now takes planning it didn't require a year ago. If you just want dinner on a Tuesday, nothing about your Tuesday has changed at all.
A Note For Neighbors
It's rare for a five-mile key to end up in the same conversation as a chef who's cooked at Alinea and run a three-Michelin-star kitchen of his own. Most people who live here won't reorganize their week around it, and they shouldn't have to. But if a birthday, an anniversary, or a visit from family is coming up and The Dining Room is part of the plan, it's worth making that call earlier than habit suggests.
I spend most of my time a little further north, working with buyers and sellers across the Middle and Lower Keys, but I keep an eye on stories like this one because they're part of what makes living out here different from living almost anywhere else. A five-mile island with one real restaurant just landed a level of culinary attention most mainland towns ten times its size never see. That's worth knowing whether or not it changes your Tuesday.
If you ever want to talk about what's happening on Little Torch Key beyond the dinner table, from property to the rhythms of daily life here, Jennifer Hamill is always glad to compare notes. Let's Connect.