Drive down Sadowski Causeway at dusk and the corner at 700 W. Ocean Drive looks different than it did a year ago. The old Key Colony Inn sign is gone. The dining room that spent decades in the same configuration has been gutted, the bar pushed back, the ceiling carpet replaced. For residents who took the closure as one more loss on a short island, the more interesting story is what has quietly assembled around that one address.
This is not a roundup of new places to eat. It is a note on how one operator is stitching three storefronts along the Causeway into something that will change how a KCB household plans a Tuesday.
The Reopening You Can Already See
The Inn at Key Colony is the piece most residents have already noticed. New owner Jim Figueroa brought in Michael and Amanda Lordi to run the kitchen and the front of house. Amanda came up under the previous Key Colony Inn owners Sergei and Lena Proudnik in 2013 and later managed fine dining at the Plaza Grill in Marathon; she is running the front-of-house and bar while Michael holds down the kitchen.
The concept is not a nostalgia play. The vision is to open The Inn at Key Colony as a true fine dining restaurant, complete with craft cocktails and powered by a from-scratch kitchen. The build-out reflects that. The bar has been shifted back to make room for booth seating and a more open lounge feel, the old dining room furniture is gone, and the carpet is off the ceiling, replaced by fresh paint and paneling.
On the plate, the direction is Italian meets chophouse. The Inn at Key Colony is positioned as an elevated dining destination offering a fusion of Italian homemade cuisine and premium chop house steakhouse classics, blending handmade pastas, house-made sauces, and seasonal antipasti with wet-aged cuts, prime steaks, and artisan sides, paired with a curated wine and cocktail program.
Service hours are the practical detail worth writing down. Lunch runs 11:00 am to 3:00 pm, happy hour 11:00 am to 5:00 pm, and dinner 5:00 pm to 9:00 pm, Monday and Tuesday and Thursday through Sunday. Closed Wednesdays. Reservations skew resort casual, not beachwear.
The Pattern Behind The Reopening
Here is the piece most neighbors have not connected yet. The Inn is not a standalone project. It is the anchor of a three-address strategy Figueroa is running along the Causeway.
The Lordis were originally hired to open a newly built restaurant called Water's Edge along Sadowski Causeway before the Key Colony assignment landed on top of it. The Inn opened first because the building was there. Water's Edge is the ground-up build.
The two restaurants are being run as one operation. With an abundance of storage and prep space, the Inn's kitchen will serve as a commissary for both restaurants, along with an upcoming convenience store and sandwich shop at the former site of Causeway Pizza.
Read that sentence carefully. It has three implications for anyone who lives here:
- The Inn's kitchen is doing more work than its own menu. The from-scratch program was sized for a commissary, not just a dining room. That is why the build-out prioritized prep space over seat count.
- Water's Edge is where lunch goes. The Inn is not initially focused on lunch service, and that gap is meant to be filled by a spring opening of Water's Edge. If you have been waiting for a real sit-down lunch option on the Causeway that is not a resort dining room, spring is the target.
- The old Causeway Pizza corner is coming back as something different. A convenience store and sandwich shop is a much more useful daily amenity for KCB residents than another dinner concept. It is the piece that changes weekday routines the most.
The Three-Address Map
For the residents who like to see it laid out:
| Address / Location | Concept | Status |
|---|---|---|
| 700 W. Ocean Drive | The Inn at Key Colony, Italian-chophouse fine dining | Open, lunch through dinner Mon–Tue and Thu–Sun |
| Sadowski Causeway, new build | Water's Edge, expected to carry lunch service | Targeted spring opening |
| Former Causeway Pizza site | Convenience store and sandwich shop | Announced, opening TBD |
Three storefronts, one kitchen behind them. That is not the usual pattern for a two-square-mile island. It is closer to how a resort campus organizes food and beverage, and it is being built by a private operator on a public causeway.
What Changes For A Tuesday Night
The practical read for a KCB household looks like this.
Reservations become the norm, not the exception. The Inn is small, it is running a from-scratch kitchen, and the room is being marketed as date-night. Walk-in Fridays are not the plan. Build the habit of booking earlier in the week or grabbing the 5:00 p.m. happy hour window, which starts the moment lunch service ends.
The happy hour overlap is unusual. Lunch and happy hour both run in the 11-to-5 block. That is a soft-open bar setup meant to catch the between-meal crowd that KCB actually has a lot of, boaters coming off the water at 2 p.m., snowbirds finishing a walk, contractors between jobs. Most Middle Keys restaurants do not staff for that window.
Wednesdays are the quiet night. The Inn is closed. That leaves the standing options on the island and the short drive across the bridge.
The Rest Of The Walkable Dinner Map
Nothing about the Causeway build-out replaces what is already working on the island. It just adds a top layer.
Havana Jack's Oceanside is still the sunset option on the ocean side of Ocean Drive. It is an open-air restaurant featuring fresh local seafood, Cuban and Caribbean-inspired flavors, sweeping ocean views, and live music, suited to laid-back lunches, sunset cocktails, and dinners by the water. Reservations there matter most on weekends and holiday evenings.
The short drive north across the causeway opens up Sparky's Landing, Island Fish Co., and Keys Fisheries for casual seafood, plus Lighthouse Grill inside Faro Blanco for a marina-side sit-down. South of the bridges, Duck Key gives you Angler & Ale and the newer Salt + Ash at Hawks Cay when the occasion calls for it.
None of those are new. What is new is that KCB now has a fine-dining anchor on-island rather than a required drive off it. For homeowners who bought here in part because the island felt self-contained, that closes a small but real gap.
Why This Matters Beyond Dinner
A single operator concentrating three food-and-beverage addresses on one causeway is a signal about how KCB is being read as a market. It says a private investor sees enough year-round demand, not just seasonal traffic, to justify a ground-up build plus a full kitchen commissary. The convenience store piece in particular is a bet on daily resident spending, not on visitors picking up a sandwich once a week in February.
For residents thinking about what their home actually offers day to day, that shift matters more than a menu. Walkable dinner, walkable lunch, and a walkable place to grab a loaf of bread and a bottle of wine on the way home are three different things. KCB is closer to having all three within the same two blocks than it has been in a long time.
If you are weighing what the neighborhood feels like right now, or thinking through how these changes read into the value of a home a few streets away from the Causeway, Jennifer Hamill lives on the island and follows this map in person. Let's Connect.