"Hay veces mucho, hay veces poco. Cuando mucho, mucha mercancía, poco dinero. Cuando poca mercancía, más precio."
Orestes Cordero said that two days before the season opened, standing on the dock behind Keys Fisheries with a concrete-weighted trap at his feet. As translated by the Key West Citizen and Florida Keys Free Press, it means: sometimes a lot, sometimes a little. When there's a lot, lots of product, little money. When there's little product, a higher price. He has worked that dock for 11 years, "first as a worker, now as an owner," and he fishes a small license of about 50 traps.
A week into the 2026–27 season, those four sentences explain the claw price at Marathon's fish house better than any menu board. Nobody prints the price ahead of time. The traps decide it, and they decide it again every day.
Nobody Knows the Number Until the First Trap Comes Up
Stone crab season opened Thursday, Oct. 15. Traps went into the water to soak on Oct. 5, and under Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission rules they could not be pulled until opening day. Scott Dekle, vice president of Keys Fisheries, told the Citizen that boats leave around 4 a.m., and when the traps sit 30 miles out, a crew rides two hours before reaching the first one. "No one knows the catch until the first trap comes up," the paper reported.
That schedule also explains why claws show up in the afternoon. Lobster is still in season, so it gets cooked first thing in the morning. "The crab won't be till later in the day," Dekle said. Down on Stock Island, Brandon Geide of Keys Fresh Seafood made the same point about opening day: boats get in late on the 15th, the claws still have to be cooked, so the counter really fills on the 16th.
Three Things Set the Menu Price
At Shannon's Crustacean Station, the upstairs tiki bar at Keys Fisheries, the menu has no stone crab price on it. Manager Kathy Perez told the Citizen the number depends on three things:
- "How big is the Stone Crab." Larger claws cost more per pound.
- "How much is the pound." This is the dock price, which goes up and down with Cordero's mucho and poco.
- "The cost of the gas." The boats that make two-hour runs burn diesel, and that cost is passed along.
Bartender Lauren Barbush put the third one more bluntly before the opener: "I have no idea what the price is. Especially with the cost of diesel and everything now." Stock Island tells the same story. Martin Rahming at Fishbusterz said the first pull of the season sets the market price, and "supply demand is going to be the hugest one for sure."
So the price you saw this past week reflects the catch, the claw size and fuel costs on the days you bought.
The Season Has a Price Curve
The daily swings ride on a larger pattern. Geide described a season that runs in three stages, and that tells you more about when to buy than any single day's price.
| Point in the season | What happens to price, per Geide |
|---|---|
| Beginning of the season | Higher, "when it's more in need" |
| Toward the end of the season | "Drops down" |
| Around Christmas | "Shoots back up" |
Geide also put the current season in context. Claw prices hit "an extreme spike" around COVID-19 and are "slowly coming back to that normal."
Last season offers a rough benchmark. In late October 2025, the Miami Herald published retail estimates of $31 to $34 a pound for mediums, $45 to $47 for large and $51 to $53 for extra-large. A second source in the same story put mediums at $35 to $40, large at $50 to $60 and jumbo at $65 to $75. Those were 2025 opening-season prices across South Florida, not this year's Marathon prices. The Herald also reported that prices that fall were higher than the year before, citing labor and the cost of keeping boats and traps up. One operator estimated that 5% to 10% of traps are lost each year.
The early-season premium shows up the moment the traps go in. In Key Largo, the office at Key Largo Fisheries told the Citizen that phones were ringing with orders before the boats left, some customers had been on the list for months, and pre-order shipments were set to start on the 20th. Distributors around the country are bidding for the same first claws that land in Marathon.
The Rules That Shrink Supply Came From the Fishermen
Part of the supply story is a choice the industry made on purpose. FWC's rule history shows that changes taking effect Oct. 1, 2020, moved the season's end to May 1 and raised the minimum claw size to 2 7/8 inches. Dekle told the Citizen it "wasn't just FWC coming up with something on their own." Organized fishermen sat down with state staff in structured meetings because "our catch keeps going down."
He listed three changes:
- The minimum claw grew by an eighth of an inch. "An eighth of an inch doesn't sound like much," he said.
- Traps now need an escape ring placed so that when a trap comes up, draining water carries small crabs out with it.
- The season lost two weeks in May, after a state biologist told him that in the first half of May, more than half of the female crabs were carrying eggs.
Each of those rules means fewer claws reach the counter in a given season. That is part of what "poco" means in practice. Dekle said scientists talked about six to 10 years before the benefits would show. Cordero summed up the season this way: "Es una buena historia, pero no garantizada." A good story, but nothing guaranteed.
On the Water
Chris Day, manager of the Half Shell Raw Bar in Key West and a former dive master, told the Citizen that when he comes across a trap while snorkeling, "If it's not your trap, you don't get near it." Before the opener, FWC told the paper that officers would be on the water that week looking for early harvesters, and that the agency has added long-range cameras, night vision and underwater cameras on patrol vessels.
If you catch a tagged stone crab, FWC asks you to report the tag number, date and location to 786-492-0137 or [email protected], and to leave the tagged claw on the crab. The agency has offered a $500 raffle prize to people who report.
Oct. 31 at Keys Fisheries
The season's first big night out comes before most traps have been pulled more than a few times. Keys Fisheries holds its 15th annual Stone Crab Eating Contest on Saturday, Oct. 31. Entry is $75 for one contestant or $150 for a two-person team, according to the contest page. The page does not list a start time or this year's format. Last year, Keys Weekly reported that the contest used 25 claws and that entry fees benefited the Florida Keys Hope Walk. Check with Keys Fisheries for the 2026 details.
The contest falls inside Geide's high-demand opening weeks, so every claw on those plates will have been priced on an early-season dock.
If you have questions about this season or how a dock works on a particular canal, Jennifer Hamill is happy to share what she knows from living and boating in the Middle Keys. Let's connect.